What I Have Learned About Leaders and Endings

Leaders are praised for not giving up.

Very few are taught when to stop.

The traits that build things

There is a great deal of good in a leader who refuses to quit. Tenacity. Passion. The willingness to fight against the norm and forge new territory.

Think of the people who sailed across oceans to reach new lands. The pilgrims. The families who went west. The pioneers on every frontier. They did not give up easily. If they had, a great many things we now take for granted would never have been built.

Those traits push us forward. They are part of what makes a leader a leader.

But those same traits can also be tied to ego. And when they are, they can keep a leader holding on long after something has died.

Strength and wisdom

A good leader needs the strength to shut things down.

A good leader also needs the wisdom to know when to shut things down.

The second one is harder. It may be the subject of a lesson all its own: how do we actually know when the end has come?

But once we do know, once an initiative, an employee, or even a leader within an organization has proven time and time again to do more harm than good, keeping it in place only continues the damage. The same is true of a bad principle, a bad policy, or a bad practice that everyone knows is not working.

At that point, holding on is not loyalty. It is prolonging the hurt.

Where I was weak

I need to be honest here, because this is not a lesson I learned by watching other people.

Knowing when to end things was an area where I was extremely weak as a pastor.

I was poor at letting go of staff who were ineffective and leaders who were ineffective. Many times I put the friendship and the relationship ahead of whether the person could actually do the job in front of them. And because of that, the church suffered. Programs suffered.

Looking back, I cannot think of a single time I delayed an ending and later felt I had done the right thing.

Some people come into our lives for a season. They are good in a role up to a certain point. But when they cannot grow as the organization grows, they become a weight on it. You try to save the friendship, and many times you end up losing the friendship anyway.

If I could go back, I would change that. I would move people out of positions a lot quicker.

The ending I delayed most

The hardest example is personal, and I will only speak for myself.

People often say they stayed married for the children. I have joked that I stayed married for the church. I was afraid of the damage an ending would do to the congregation.

In reality, I brought more damage to the church by not moving on. In the end, I was the instigator of my own undoing as a leader and as a pastor. That delay brought harm to the church, to my family, and to close friends.

It is nearly impossible to think clearly when you are struggling just to survive. If I had made more precise changes earlier, yes, there would have been consequences. But not nearly as bad as the consequences of waiting.

Why we indulge people

Most leaders I know do not keep failing things alive because they are careless. They do it because they care.

We indulge people because we do not want to seem heartless.

And there is a real reason it feels that way. Whenever someone is let go, or told no, or moved out of a role, they have to go through a whole set of psychological adjustments. They have to reframe their future. They have to re-envision what they thought their life was going to look like.

A leader with a conscience feels the weight of that.

That is where the rub comes. You have competing desires, competing visions, and competing priorities, and you care about the people on every side of them.

But here is what I have learned. In the name of care, we can become the very thing we would never want to be. We prolong the pain. We become, without ever meaning to, the one who drags it out.

The vision is entrusted to you

I believe there is a unique vision given to leaders. I would say it comes from above. You may call it intuition or calling. Either way, when you have been entrusted with leadership, you cannot afford to let everything and everybody who wants to come along take that vision away from you.

A vision attracts people. That is part of its power. But people are not always drawn to the vision itself. Many are drawn to the excitement, the newness, and the chance to accomplish something they have never been able to do anywhere else.

I saw this most in the church world, especially among volunteers, but it happens in business too. Someone is drawn to your calling because they were not successful in other places. They come into what you were called to build, and soon there are two competing paths running inside the same work. It may not look like open competition. But there is no real unity or harmony. It was rare to find someone who truly supported both the vision and the leadership.

I pastored a large group of people from many different backgrounds, and I believe I did that well. But eventually some of those same people contributed to my downfall. When they saw I was weak as a leader, they moved, because they had their own vision for what I had built.

You see this in churches. You see it in business. You see it in friendships.

So when you have been given the gift of leadership, you have to learn to say no to some of the people who want to hitch their wagon to your horse. Very often, they are trying to attach something that never worked on its own to something that does.

That does not mean you stop recruiting. You want to attract talent. You want to hire people who can help move the vision forward. But you cannot let go of the vision itself. So many leaders compromise what they could have done because they allowed others to attach themselves and pull the work off course.

Do not poison the well

There is something else I have watched happen over and over when a new church starts, when a new business opens, or when something new and fresh comes along.

People arrive who were frustrated and disappointed with the systems they came from. Life had become very difficult where they were. They came because the new thing offered hope, freedom, and the possibility of a future.

But many of them did not only bring their hope. They brought the same systems that had made life untenable where they came from.

And then, without meaning to, they begin putting those systems back in place. In businesses. In families. Even in themselves.

It is like finding a fresh well after a long, dry season, and then pouring into it the same thing that contaminated the old one. We end up hurting ourselves and others in the very place where we found life.

A leader has to guard the well.

When the world changes and the schedule does not

Sometimes what needs to end is not a person. It is a practice.

When the church I pastored first started, there was not a great deal for people to do in the community. There were not many chances to travel or many activities competing for time. Religion also drew a hard line: you went to church, or you participated in the world.

Then the world changed. Families changed. What people chose to be involved in changed.

I remember a time when I could not imagine not having church on Sunday nights, or not having a midweek service in the same format we always had.

My father was always faithful to the church. He was there every time the doors were open. So I will never forget laughing when, later in life, he told me the church he was attending just had way too much going on. Church three or four times a week.

Years earlier, that would have been completely normal to him. Maybe he was older and tired. Maybe his priorities had shifted. He was not being critical. He would just rather be home resting.

But it said something true. Churches try to give something to everybody. And in the process, the most faithful people end up giving far too much of themselves.

When a leader keeps every program alive because it has always been there, you wear out the very people you most depend on. You can see the same slow torture we have been talking about through this whole series, only now it is happening to a congregation or a team.

Things naturally change. Leaders have to be willing to let some things end with them.

The sharp knife

Throughout this series, I have come back to one image: a counselor once told me that when an ending has come, you use a sharp knife. Not to be harsh. To be merciful.

Leadership is no different.

Once you know, there needs to be a clean cut and a clean end. Say it plainly. Say it with dignity. Then let everyone involved, including the person who is leaving, begin the work of building what comes next.

And then trust. Trust that there is something on the other side of this ending. I would call it trusting God. You may call it trusting the way the world works. Either way, what is past this can be just as good, if not better, than what you are holding on to now.

What I have learned

Tenacity builds organizations. Wisdom protects them.

A leader who cannot end anything will eventually end up protecting everything except the mission.

Caring about people is not the same as keeping them in the wrong place. Delaying an ending does not spare anyone the consequences. It only makes them worse. And protecting the vision you were given sometimes means telling people, kindly and clearly, that they cannot come with you.

If we trust Him for tomorrow, we do not have to be afraid to let go today.

The DKP Word 2026
Read the work. Share the work. Support the work.
#LiveBetterLeadBetter

David Payne